[editors note: welcome Ish to the stable of MSR writers with his recent musings on American Idol. Look for more if Ish's writing in the coming weeks and in the meantime check out his blog.]
I’m a fan of American Idol and I like Randy Jackson, but seriously, I’m not sure he has a firm grip on the meaning of numbers. Example:
Randy listens to auditioner #1. He’s good. Simon says yes, Paula says yes. What does Randy say?
“For me it’s a thousand percent yes, dog. Welcome to Hollywood!”
Cut to auditioner #2. She is also good. Simon says yes, Paula weeps and says “you have a beautiful heart,” Simon audibly rolls his eyes. And Randy says:
“One million percent yes! You’re going to Hollywood!”
Did Randy really like auditioner #2 a thousand times more than he liked auditioner #1? Does Randy mean it when he conveys to us the fact that he believes that singer #1 has only 0.001 as much talent as singer #2? I doubt it. I suspect he has a limited capacity to understand the meaning of numbers. let me explain…
Read the rest of Ish's post »