America’s Next Top Model: The Possibility of Unperceived Existence

0_LauraNicWoods1118So it’s happened again, another cycle of ANTM has come and gone, like the seasonal flu. Betcha  thought I wasn’t going to get around to recapping this thing. To be honest, I had my doubts too, but I’m determined to drag out the hammer and put the final nails in this “petite” sized coffin.

Let’s face it, this season was pretty meh. Tyra may have tossed little people in the mix to liven things up, but she also managed to remove a lot of the drama. I like both of the finalists, yet I can’t say I really care who wins, partly because, much like the Governership of California, I’m not really sure this is a contest worth winning.

At least the contestants still think it’s worth being anointed by Tyra. Most of the episode is devoted to their appreciation of how Tyra and her magical show has changed their lives. Laura dreams of saving her kinfolk from a life of squirrel eating out in rural Kentucky. Perhaps they can add reality show television to the stimulus funding; it seems to be how our nation’s youth dreams of lifting itself out of poverty. College and book learnin’ dosn’t seem to be doing the trick.

Nicole, in turn, credits Tyra with breaking her out of her depressive shell. Once too shy to speak in front of class, now, thanks to Tyra, she’s fondled acrobats, played a Japanese-Malagasy, and smized on national television.  Please let this be the end of your loosened inhibitions, Nicole. I’d hate to see you turn up on Rock of Love 12: The Herpocalypse.

All this self revelation takes place as Nicole and Laura cavort around the enormous, empty mansion. It’s like Home Alone with models. In the hot tub, Nicole admits Laura was the first girl she related to, while Laura confesses she thought Nicole was snotty, on account of her big city words and ability to operate parking meters. Just kiss already, you two.


The penultimate Tyra mail, thank Jebus. I know that damn safe will be back to haunt me next cycle though. It reads, “If a model falls in the forest, will anybody hear it?” A more or less complete mangling of the thought question “If a tree falls in the forest and no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound?”  and its corollary “If Tyra talks about herself and no one listens, does she cease to exist?”


“Does a model shit in the woods?”

It’s the Cover Girl commercial! They’ve received the scripts along with the mangled philosophy vis-á-vis forests and sound. Nicole immediately senses an advantage over poor, dyslexic Laura. Little does she know, the commercial involves horse castration. Advantage Laura.

The girls tumble into the huge van, specially outfitted with child seats for the midget season, and journey deep into the Hawaiian woods. A forest elf greets the travelers.


Nicole tackels the elf and holds him down while Laura forces him to divulge where he hides his pot o’gold.  I kid, it’s Jay Manuel and his pea coat made from actual peas. And look! Who that hiding behind a tree? It’s what’s-her-name, the winner from last cycle! (She really was hiding behind a tree.)


“Hi! I’m not dead!”

Jay announces they’ll be shooting both the commercial and the WalMart ad in some sort of complex sequence, probably because they’ve only rented to forest for an hour, in between the Jankowitz-Patel Wedding and the Maui Druid Society Annual Sacrifice and Marshmallow Roast. Teyona does her best to hawk the latest CoverGirl marketing disaster, EyeGouge or LashRash or whatever it is. There’s a good five minutes of her circulating around the make-up area like a sales woman on commission. Hang in there, Teyona, you’re almost free! You just need to trick another into taking your place!


Continuing this cycle’s cheapskate theme, Nigel returns to shoot the Walmart ad. And in yet another cost-saving measure, a park ranger directs the commercial.


But let’s get to the filming. Laura goes first (while Nicole does her shoot with Nigel – time is money, people!). Will the tortured prose excreted by the CoverGirl copywriters defeat her? Almost. She stumbles at first, possibly because “Lash Blast” is a stupendously bad name for a product, but she pulls herself together, heartened by the thought of buying Wanda Sue an electric sewing machine to replace the wood-burning one.

While Laura struggles with reading because of her dyslexia, Nicole’s handicap is far more deadly, model-wise. She seems smart. Oh no! No one wants to be like the smart girl! We all remember the debacle of the Ruth Bader Ginsburg BlushFlusher campaign. Jay worries that Nicole sounds like she doesn’t take the product seriously. This of course, just makes me like Nicole more. No one should take “Lash Blast” seriously. The number of takes mount up, ominously. Eventually someone must have lobotomized Nicole, because they got the appropriate level of air-headedness the product requires.


During the photo shoot, Nigel chokes out a couple “smile with your eyes” but to his credit, refuses to say “smizing.” Stay strong, Nigel. The English language is depending on you. Nicole, as usual, performs very well, and as a reward gets an awkward hug from Nigel. Nigel is less enthused about Laura, mostly because when he asked her what she thought about to produce the needed happy emotion for the shoot, she replied “milkshake.” The proper answer, apparently, was “Nigel” or even “Tyra.” Sorry, Nigel, but sometimes a gal just really wants a milkshake, you know?


“Milkshakes …. puppies … castration … “

Afterwards the girls return to the house. Teyona returns to her post behind the tree, jumping out at hikers, screeching “Lash Blast! Laaaaaasssssh Blaaaaasssssssst!” The hikers awaken hours later, naked, confused, and covered in an array of poorly marketed cosmetics.

Over at the mansion, Ann Shoket stops by to supervise the cover shoot, where “cover” means the inside flap of Seventeen. The actual cover will be of someone capable of shunting a few more dollars into magazine’s dying veins. Like maybe that Kristen Stewart. Mormon sparkle vamps are so hot right now. They’ll do the not-cover shoot right there in the house. Jebus, they really are spending zero money. Either that or the girls are under some sort of house arrest. Quarantine? I can rule none of these things out.


“Just stay here. There’s nothing to see in Hawaii, trust me. Might as well stay in and watch TV.”

Photographer Gilles Bensimon, best known as having once been married to the ball of crazy that is Kelly Bensimon, will shoot the photo. You know, having seen the depths of insanity to which this man was willing to be joined in holy matrimony, his friendship with Tyra is much more understandable. Tyra’s a stable genius compared to Kelly.

But I digress. There’s another boring photoshoot, where the girls are dressed in supremely ugly outfits. They can be consoled by the fact few people will see them, as the actual cover will probably be Heidi Montag. Or they can weep for humanity. A little from column A and a little from column B, I suppose.


Laura is wearing a tube top over a tank top, paired with long, fingerless pink gloves, and a necklace that looks suspiciously like bottlecaps.

After the shoot, the girls rattle about the mansion, practice their walks, and try to remember what life on the outside was like. Nicole tries to build a radio out of coconuts and palm leaves, before realizing that only worked on Gilligan’s Island. Laura manages to capture a bird and ties a help message to its legs. Sadly, her dyslexia caused her to write “Save styra foam” instead of “Save us from Tyra” and is interpreted by it’s finder as campaign to stop littering.

But wait, help has arrived! Not that they get to leave, or anything. Tyra arrives to help them get all the admiration they have for Tyra off their chest. She’s giving like that. They’ve been dying to let Tyra know how much she’s helped them, nay, all dwarf models, nay, all of humanity. Naturally Tyra beats them to the punch, immediately bringing up how groundbreaking it is to have “petite” models like 5’7 Nicole.

Besides the Tyra adulation, it’s a chance for the girls to share their pain and feed Tyra’s Oprah fantasies. By the way, how psyched is Tyra that Oprah announced her retirement? Anyway, Nicole confesses that she used to eat her lunch in the bathroom to avoid other students. And now, Tyra points out, she’s a finalist! Psychological problems solved! She can join the legions of other reality show contestants reveling in their newfound mental stability.

Laura, of course, discusses how trapped she felt in rural Kentucky. Before the show she thought models came from outer space! At least that’s what Uncle Cletus kept saying. She’s starting to suspect his story about being taken on board the mothership and forced to have sex with Heidi Klum wasn’t true. And the thing he gave Aunt Brandine wasn’t astro-syphilis, after all. Tyra assures Laura she’s beautiful on the inside too.


“You’re at least 5’10 on the inside.”

Finally, the girls tunnel out of the house, flag down a passing driver and escape. It’s the runway show! All the girls who made it to Hawaii have stuck around to walk in the show. Genius! They save on models, and can keep the group rate for the return flight. Inexplicably, Eddie Murphy’s daughter is also walking, although she is not a model. Product placement?


Paths to a Modeling Job: 1) Hard work and good looks 2) Reality show contest 3) Famous parents

All the models are coated in glitter (I blame you for this, Twilight sparklevamps) and given horrible dresses. But no runway show is complete without a ludicrous theme. Rob forbid models should just walk down the runway and show the clothes. This show’s theme is the elements: fire, wind, and water. Sorry earth, they’ve been over you since the half-assed green cycle.


Feel the excitement

They’ve really gone all out for this show. They’ve borrowed the paper mâché volcano the Lokelani Middle School used for their spring dance. Miss J has broken down and worn the grass skirt he’s been dying to put on since they got there. Tyra is wearing a one-sleeved muumuu. Actually, if she paired that dress with a turban, it would be awesome in a Norma-Desmond-goes-on-vacation kind of way. Oh, and Eddie Murphy takes a break from whatever it is Eddie Murphy does these days to watch his daughter capitalize on being the fruit of his loins.

So anyway, I suppose we have to talk about the show. As I mentioned the dresses are hideous, even by this show’s standards. Nicole in particular gets a weird disco-victorian dress whose only connection to the element of fire is that flames may be the kindest fate for that travesty. Nicole’s walk is similarly terrible and blundering. Her shoulders swing like she’s aiming to punch you in the face once she reaches the end of the runway. Perhaps the designer.


Laura’s walk is much better, although her arms are quite stiff. She’s decked out in a nude-covered slip to which some intern starting gluing aluminum foil scraps only to give up halfway through.


After fire, the models dash backstage to get reshellaced with glitter and prepare for wind. Continuing their stunning display of literalism, the wind segment had, naturally, wind. If that’s not enough, the models have to stride out covered in sheer fabric, before dramatically removing it at the end of the runway. Besides hammering home the wind theme harder than a carpenter on steroids, the scarf provides other potential benefits: (1) it blinds the models, raising the potential for model collisions; (2) potential entanglement of the model during removal at the end of the runway; (3) it hides the ugly clothes. Sadly, only the last benefit actually appears, and only until the models take the covering off.


Having successfully completed wind, the models change for water. Is there any doubt it will involve actual water? At least they get to wear bathing suits. Wouldn’t want to ruin those awesome dresses! Instead they all wear identical, cheap bikinis that were clearly purchased in bulk, and clumsily draped with sheer fabric. It’s obviously not part of the line and just an opportunity to cram the models awkwardly together under a shower.


After backstage hugs from Tyra, Nicole and Laura get to remove the glitter, but must wear their ugly dresses again for the final judging. At least it give me a better screencap of the fugliness.


See what I mean? At least they finally get to wear heels, just like real, grown-up models. The judges are surprisingly kind to Nicole about her walk. While they think it’s lumbering, they also agree that it’s “signature.” Isn’t that the kind of wrong-headed thinking they spend time beating out of the girls? Miss J is surprisingly silent on the subject, or maybe he popped a shirt-sleeve. Laura receives better marks.

I won’t spend time on the old pics that the judges waded through. I was sorely tempted to fast-forward through the whole section, especially since Tyra once again says crazy things about looking tall, by which she means thin.

FINALLY, we get to the commercials. The actual, editied commercial composed of a million jump cuts and a squajillion takes, is actually quite cute. And it will never be seen again. Oh, what the hell, here it is.

They are not quite so smooth in their best takes. Laura seems very nervous, perhaps appropriately so, since she’s dealing with a product whose name suggests it will blow-up in her eye. Nigel complains he can’t understand her accent, the elitist bastard. Laura confesses she hasn’t understood a word Nigel’s said all season. They love her photo, calling it simple and clean. It’s nice, but not really a major ad-campaign photo. More of an actress head shot photo.


Nicole’s best take is much better, and quite toothy. Given they’ve pardoned her awful runway walk, she’s cruising right into the win. If they were going to hand it to Nicole, they would have given her a far more bitchy edit. For Nicole’s photo, Tyra admires her ability to be relaxed but confident. I admire her ability to wear vast amounts of blush.


They wrap up with a lot of gushing about how wonderful the gals are. Nigel says they prived that “who you are is relevant” which, while I agree that who you are is relevant, I wouldn’t say they exactly proved. Was it in their ability to look tall-thin? I’m secretly hopeful that they’ll decide that two short models equals one tall model, and let them both win.

During deliberation, there’s some body-snarking as Miss J has issues with Laura’s proportions and Nigel has issues with Nicole’s, although I am not exactly clear why.

Nicole wins! This make me happy. Laura cries. They should let her castrate something as a consolation prize. They send her back to Kentucky where they can regale the folks with her strange tales of parking meters and towering puffy-sleeved ambiguously gendered runway coaches.


Nicole is whisked off to a photo shoot, set up in the hallway, as the studio rental runs out in an our, and they have to break down the set before they lose their deposit. Nigel snaps a few photos while Tyra smizes it up, sliently counting her millions.


Fun fact: Hawaii produces 88% of the US supply of static electricity.

Oh, and one more thing! You know the song they play during the weepy model exits at the end of the program? The one that goes “top moooodel, top moooodel” all autotuned to hell? Sure you do. Well here it is. The whole thing, just like you never wanted. I dare you to make it all the way to the end. I couldn’t. (There’s no real video, just the photo and the audio.)

So what did you think? Do you still care or remember? Did Tyra help you understand that short people aren’t monsters, they just look like them?

I’m torn about covering next cycle. Frankly, I was going to throw in the towel and cover something else, in my lazy, perpetually behind schedule way (suggestions?). On the other hand, it’s just so hard to quit what’s become a socio-anthropological study of Tyra’s brain. Plus, I have heard (spoilers!) that the next cycle will travel to New Zealand., which brings up the possibility of a Lord of the Rings themed shoot. So, should I stay or should I go?

brilliantmistake | 12.03.09 | Filed in America's Next Top Model,Recaps

Back to the top

28 responses to “America’s Next Top Model: The Possibility of Unperceived Existence”

  1. marslo says:

    Stay! I love your ANTM recaps! Thanks for finishing out the season.

    Nicole is my favourite ANTM contestant possibly ever, so I was very happy with the outcome.

  2. Karo says:

    I am also torn. While I think your recaps are fantastic, I’m not sure I can make it through another season, uh, cycle, of ANTM. Personally, I wish you would just quit your real job and recap all of the shows I watch.

    Those dresses…Miss J’s sleeves…oy.

  3. may says:

    Fantastic job Brill. Thanks for all you did this season, making it more tolerable. Tyra is just too much fun to make fun of.
    I agree with Karo, I wish you’d recap all our shows.

  4. terpsichory says:

    I’ll humour you and beg (just like last cycle),
    but your recaps are smizing gems of rhetorical finesse and I wouldn’t want to miss them for the world (of Tyra).
    This recap was particularly great, so thanks for that and your whole coverage.
    I also believe the show is quite educational. I, for instance, won’t spend another night without going H to T.
    (That’s Himbeergeist to Tequila, right?)

  5. brilliantmistake says:

    Thanks all. I’m just not sure if I shouldn’t give some other show the love/hate I have to share. Like maybe Project Runway.

    On the other hand, I’m already fantasizing that Tyra won’t be able to get permission to use LOR characters and we’ll have a hilarious photo shoot involving “shmorcs” and “hoobbits,” so I guess I’m already hooked. Damn you, Tyra.

  6. Lasco Ford says:

    I’m impressed, I must say. Really not often do I encounter a weblog that’s both educative and entertaining, and let me let you know, you could have hit the nail on the head. Your thought is excellent; the issue is something that not enough persons are talking intelligently about. I am very happy that I stumbled throughout this in my search for something regarding this.

  7. Priante says:

    I have been browsing online greater than 3 hours today, but I never discovered any fascinating article like yours. It is lovely price sufficient for me. Personally, if all website owners and bloggers made just right content material as you probably did, the net shall be much more useful than ever before.

  8. increase your followers says:

    Its like you learn my mind! You appear to know so much approximately this, such as you wrote the e book in it or something. I believe that you could do with a few percent to force the message home a bit, but other than that, this is excellent blog. A great read. I will definitely be back.

  9. fiftyflowers reviews says:

    I think this is among the most important information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on few general things, The site style is great, the articles is really nice : D. Good job, cheers

  10. Cassi Maravilla says:

    Hmm it appears like your website ate my first comment (it was super long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I wrote and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog writer but I’m still new to the whole thing. Do you have any points for newbie blog writers? I’d genuinely appreciate it.

  11. Takako Pascher says:

    I wished to variety a basic term to express gratitude to you for these awesome suggestions you’re sharing on this web site. My considerable world-wide-web search has now been compensated with reasonable information to alternate with my co-staff. I would assert that most of us internet site readers are surely endowed to exist in a excellent neighbourhood with many fantastic folks with really valuable ideas. I really feel really fortunate to have occur across the weblog and glance ahead to a lot of much more thrilling periods perusing here. Thank you the moment a lot more for lots of issues.

  12. zyczenia urodziny says:

    We’re a congregate of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community. Your web position offered us with helpful data to paintings by. You’ve performed an impressive task and our full categorize will almost certainly ensue thankful to you.

  13. sennik polski internet says:

    Outstanding post, I think website owners should acquire a lot from this blog its very user genial. So much great info on here :D.

  14. helmets motorcycle full face says:

    Many thankfulness for creating the effort to argue this, I consider solidly regarding this and enjoy studying a abundant split more taking place this subject. Proviso sufficient, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your website with a great pact extra info? It’s truly beneficial for me.

  15. Soon Basurto says:

    Township Meeting Set For Monday, Irrespective of Road Trip Reduced Pottsgrove commissioners canceled their previous manifeste session on April 19. They don’t seem to be most likely to miss two in a row, regardless if the board president is on an “international tour.”

  16. Eric Scheidt says:

    Many thanks Getty! We can’t wait around to receive started off!

  17. Lee Tierney says:

    Hello! I know this is kinda off topic however , I’d figured I’d ask. Would you be interested in exchanging links or maybe guest authoring a blog post or vice-versa? My site covers a lot of the same topics as yours and I think we could greatly benefit from each other. If you are interested feel free to send me an email. I look forward to hearing from you! Excellent blog by the way!

  18. Marcelino Valero says:

    Great post. I used to be checking continuously this weblog and I am impressed! Very helpful info specially the last phase :) I take care of such info much. I used to be seeking this certain info for a long time. Thanks and good luck.

  19. distilled vinegar says:

    I want to show some appreciation to this writer for bailing me out of this particular incident. Because of looking throughout the world-wide-web and meeting basics which were not beneficial, I was thinking my entire life was over. Being alive without the presence of answers to the problems you have resolved by way of your entire write-up is a crucial case, and the kind which may have negatively damaged my career if I had not noticed your web site. Your personal mastery and kindness in touching almost everything was tremendous. I’m not sure what I would’ve done if I had not discovered such a point like this. I can at this point look forward to my future. Thanks for your time very much for this high quality and result oriented guide. I won’t hesitate to recommend your blog post to any individual who should get direction about this subject.

  20. centrala says:

    Some genuinely intriguing details, properly written and usually user genial .

  21. vitamin c for face says:

    I have witnessed that costs for internet degree experts tend to be an excellent value. Like a full Bachelors Degree in Communication in the University of Phoenix Online consists of 60 credits with $515/credit or $30,900. Also American Intercontinental University Online comes with a Bachelors of Business Administration with a total education course requirement of 180 units and a tuition fee of $30,560. Online degree learning has made obtaining your degree far more easy because you can certainly earn the degree in the comfort of your house and when you finish working. Thanks for all your other tips I have certainly learned from your site.

  22. Property By Owner List Foreclosed Real Estate Louisville KY says:

    Hey I was just searching at your web site in Firefox and the image at the top of the link cant show up appropriately. Just thought I would let you know.

  23. veni vidi vici says:

    I like material like this. This really is a fantastic write-up and I truly enjoyed reading it. You’ve got an original style that makes your concepts stand out from other writers.

  24. mattress reviews says:

    Highly descriptive blog, I liked that bit. Will there be a part 2?

  25. Ayur Skin Renewal Review says:

    I real pleased to discover this website on bing, just what I was searching for : D too saved to bookmarks .

  26. websit says:

    Hello, i just planned to drop which you a line to say that we thoroughly enjoyed this specific post from yours, I have subscribed for your RSS feed and have completely skimmed several of your articles or blog posts before but this blog truly endured out in my situation.

  27. this page says:

    Wonderful write-up. I am a normal visitor of your web internet site and appreciate you taking the time to preserve the outstanding internet site. I will probably be a frequent visitor for a long time.

  28. relaxo says:

    I signed up too! My first swap as well and I am very excited!!

Leave a Comment