Project Runway: A Case of the Fabric Sh*ts

The show jumps right into the competition. This year we get no “Road to the Runway” show, which I honestly find disappointing because I always liked them in past seasons. Anyhting taht gives Tim Gunn more screentime I’m for. The first person to reach the Atlas Apartments is Rami Kashou. He has his own studio and has dressed such people as Jessica Alba, as opposed to me who would want to undress her. Hey-ooooohhhh!!!!! Anyways, His work is very foldy and drapey, like Eli Wallach’s balls. When he gets upstairs he meets Chris. Lovable fat gay guy. He specializes in “larger than life” costumes. Then we have Christian Siraino, who has the hair of a parakeet. He’s also worked with some big names. Carmen Webber was a former model turned designer. She says that she has an edge because in being a designer “if you haven’t modeled you don’t know the first thing”. Because walking in straight lines is a valuable life experience in learning how to make some grade a décolletage. Jillian works for Ralph Lauren as an illustrator and is excited about working on her own ideas for a change.

After that we meet Kit “Pistol” Scarbo, which sounds like a DC comics Villain. Then we meet Kevin. At first glance Kevin looks like a Jeffrey Sebelia 2.0. He goes out of his way in ensuring that everyone knows that he is totally not gay (but to his credit then realizes how stupid it sounded when he said it). I am currently fascinated with his beard and how it somehow achieves a strange camel hump in the middle of his cheek. Hey at least he doesn’t have a huge annoying tattoo on his adams apple. Next up is Jack. He is 100% pure, hot, glistening gay man meat. Which is the exact opposite of Steven. He’s more of a braised cabbage of a man vegetable. He works at the Museum of Science and Industry where he does sewing on various exhibits. Sound strange? Well that’s nothing compared to Elisa. She tells us that she got her start dressing freaky looking marionettes. This is frighteningly close to simply saying “I got my start making suits out of human skin”. After that we meet Marion and Ricky who both decide to wear conductor hats. Love it. Next up is Sweet P. She’s a middle aged woman who calls herself Sweet P. I admit so far it’s hard for me to really comment any further.

After they all get settled in they see a note on the table. OMFG!!! Its Tyra mail!!!!! Oh wait, its just a note form Heidi and Tim. And also the first plug of the season for Atlas apartments. They tell them to meet then at Bryant Park toot sweet.

On the way we meet the stragglers. Simone and then Marion (who owns a flower shop in Dallas). Then we meet Victorya, whose good friends with Kynt and Vyxen and all the other idiots who think purposely misspelling their names is somehow hip. When they get to Bryant Park they ruefully look at the fountain which in a scant few months will become the NY fashion week tents. Who will make it? How will I, a lowly blogger who devotes endless free publicity to Bravo though my critically acclaimed and wildly popular TV blog figure out a way to get in (hint, hint, Bravo people)? These are questions we will all learn the answers too soon enough. As they pop the champagne we get the ninja like entrance of Heidi and Tim as they appear from nowhere and surprise the contestants. Seriously, everyone acted so surprised when they appeared 3 feet from them. Were they disguised as shrubs until the last minute? Does Tim have some sort of Predator like cloaking device? If he did I imagine it would be charcoal gray to match his tie, and be much sleeker and couture looking than the ugly thing the real Predator uses. That thing was way too boxy and did not accentuate the wrist at all.

Tim points out that normally on the first challenge they get all wacky on everyone. We all remember last season where everyone ripped up upholstery or the season before that when they had the great Muslin off. This year however will be different. Not Running Man different where Schwarzenegger would turn the tables and turn Richard Dawson into the Running man (Admit it, you all want to see Kors forced to do one of those “make a dress out of horse snot” challenges. I know I do). But different nonetheless. They will be told to make an outfit that signifies who they are based on the fabrics in the tents at the other side of the park. And the tents are packed to the gills with all sorts of normal looking fabrics. A Refreshingly nice change of pace. Of course its still reality TV so in order to spice things up they go to a reality TV staple. Making a fat guy run.

It’s funny cuz he’s endangering his health!

They are given only 10 minutes to pick their fabrics and everyone races across the park with lovable Chris left behind to pant and wheeze as his grapefruit sized heart strains to pump blood to his extremities. Everyone frantically grabs at fabric with some shoving anything they can get their hands on and others taking their time and choosing something they actually like. Elisa stops and starts rubbing one of her fabrics into the ground to get grass stains on it. Not sure if that’s an interesting idea or if she is just grandstanding. Or should i say, grassstanding? I gots a million of em!

When they get back to the Parson studios Tim shows up and reminds them they have until 1 AM to get their piece together. Ricky goes with a baby doll dress, which I have grown to hate, and Simone says she is going “historical” which by taht I hope she doesn’t mean Precambrian. Rami meanwhile is draping like a mofo. At about hour three we get the first comment about Jack’s ripped ab’s, to which he feigns this faux embarrassment.

That night Tim comes by for his first Tim take! He loves Rami’s, calling it stunning. He’s worried about Simone’s saying she has a lot of work to do to get it finished. Then he gets to Elisa. Elisa has a nice simple clean lined blue evening gown with what looks like a massively multicolored piece of toilet paper stuck to the back of it. Tim warns her that the back is in “opposition” to the rest of the dress, the same way soap is in opposition to diarrhea stains. With only two hours left Elisa stops and declares that she is done. The rest of the group then frantically rushes around until the 1 AM deadline.

The next morning, after a nice lingering shot of jack moisturizing his muscles (oh, how they chaff…), we get right back to Parsons. Tim comes in and asks them to “gather round”. Oh how I get so giddy when he pops off one if his catchphrases. Speaking if which, where is my Tim Gunn See n’ Say? Instead of “the cow says moo” we can have things like “This bothers me” or “Time to caucus”. It can be covered with Timdoodles™.

This ones for the ladies. And the really gay men. And Bi-curious men. And for men like me who appreciate the naked male form but aren’t gay. Wait, that came out wrong.

After Tim does the show plugs for the “L’Oreal makeup room” and the “Bluefly shoe rack” (another thing to keep in mind, these obvious in show paid for promo’s are another form of revenue that the show generates in which writers get NO residuals) Tim introduces us to this seasons models! Yea! Oooh, so many to choose from! Which one will I develop an unhealthy creepy obsession with? We’ll figure that out later, first we get to watch a model fitting. But then it hit me. It looks like we got ourselves a bad batch.

Exhibit A

Exhibit B

Exhibit C

Exhibi- wait, actually this one looks like a keeper.

Once they go through hair and makeup they move onto the fitting portion. Elisa decides to “hand measure” her model and then runs her hands all along her models body. This is similar to what I do. Although by MY calculations her model looks about 9 penises long. But again, I’d have to penis measure her to be totally sure. After that she has her model do a test walk and it doesn’t look good. She says that the “sculptural quality” of her clumps of ripped fabric are catching the model up as she walks.

Now its time fort the runway show. Heidi comes out in a beautiful gold number. Oh how I want to steal her away by replacing her with a bag of sand….

As we all know, one day you are een, and the next day you are out. Who will win the 2007 Saturn Astro? Sure there are other prizes, but c’mon, a Saturn Astro!!!! That’s like winning a Flobee and a box of shrinky dinks all in the same day! after she dangles the prize lackage in front of us, it’s time to meet our judges. Michael Kors, Nina Garcia and guest Judge Monique Lhuillier.

Up first is Elisa’s mess. And on cue, her model trips on the runway. Not the funny trip that we’ve all come to expect, bent coccyx and all, from the internets, but more of a slight trip, which isn’t nearly as funny. What can I say, I’m a sucker for a bent coccyx.

After Chris rather pedestrian effort we see Kevin’s. Even his work looks like Jeffrey Sebelia 2.0.

Sweet P’s is kind of like a girly potato sack, and Simone’s is a bit of a mess as well. Badly stitched and conflicting styles. Jillian’s is my favorite since its a great color and really makes an impression with its silhouette (damn, would you look at me, talking all fashiony and shit?). Coming in a close second is Christians is brown and frilly and Victorya’s is actually quite nyce.

Rami’s is also pleasing to my eye if a little too toga looking for my tastes. Ricky isn’t happy with his as he thinks he needed to take some bolder choices.

Who turned on Desperate Housewives?

Jack’s is very print oriented and had an early sixties look while Marion’s looks like lingerie gone rancid. Marion’s is clean but the shock of red color “makes it work”, if you will (hmm, I think I somehow owe Tim Gunn a dime). Plus he has the read headed model and I’m always particular to those girls, even though this one looks like she’s 4. Carmen is a huge crazy mess, with hair to match. And her voiceover where she declares that it would be impossible for her to lose because her dress is too awesome. She’s in for a good dose of Kors one of these days. Kit Pistol’s dress is also quite nice with a red and black look (which seems to be a trend in this episode).

Afterwards the judges bring them out. They tell Chris, Kevin, Sweet P, Jillian, Jack, Marion, Steve, Carmen and Kit that they made it to the next round and can leave. The 6 remaining have the highest and lowest scores.

They love Christians, who says its based on European sculpture. Plus “volume is in” (Which is how Bradley’s POS from last season let him slip by a few weeks longer than he should have). They hate Simone’s. They think the sewing is horrible and the Jacket does not match the dress. Kors called it “so dressed in the dark”.

They lurve Rami’s. Sophisticated, chic, all that and a bag of chips. When they get to Elisa’s, they go off on her about her train of crap. It’s too heavy and drags the model down.

When they go into deliberations, Heidi has the best comment of all by saying Elisa’s outfit looks like her model was “pooing fabric”. And man, you haven’t lived until you’ve heard Heidi say the word “poo” in any of its tenses. Be it the present perfect “I have pooed” to the past continuous “I was pooing” to even, dare I say it, the pluperfect “I had pooed”. It’s all gravy.

Bringing the designers out they tell Victorya that she is safe. Then they announce that the winner of the competition is Rami. It’s down to Simone’s poorly constructed and uninspiring dress and Elisa’s ambitious yet overdone poo train. The judges choose to boot Simone since at least Elisa had a unique idea, even if it failed.

And with that we come to a close. What did everyone else think? Are ou as excited as I am that we have Runway back?

EdHill | 11.15.07 | Filed in Project Runway,Recaps

Back to the top

53 responses to “Project Runway: A Case of the Fabric Sh*ts”

  1. campfiregirl says:

    First Bitches!!!!

    Great Recap edhill. This is why we love you. Plus you make it work.

  2. zevonia says:

    I don’t think anyone can be as excited as you are, Ed “HairyPalms” Hill but I am excited. I liked Rami’s dress also though I would have liked to see it in a different color. I thought Chris’s dress looked great. Elisa’s dress probably could have won without the poo train and a nice pair of heels instead of those boots. But what do I know, sitting here in sweatpants and a t-shirt. Yay for Mr Gunn! I’d love a Tim Gunn See ‘N Say!

  3. campfiregirl says:

    A Tim Gunn See ‘N Say would be a moneymaker. Program in your body type and he will do his best to make you look good.

  4. honeybunny says:

    Elisa is bringing the bat shit crazy. When TimGunn told Simone her construction was lacking (which is TimGunn speak for “bitch can’t sew”) I loved how she smiled and shook her head. Then declared she was finished and went to take a nap. I smell a little Jenius here!!!1

    The more I see of Jillian’s orange Fanta dress – the more I like it. But I would totaly wear Victorya’s “I can’t raise my arms” dress. Who needs to raise their arms anyway.

    Rami’s dress was spectactular but those shoes were beyond ugly. But the prettiest thing on the show was Jack! Hubba Hubba


  5. Lizardqueen says:

    I can agree with the judges on the bottom 3, but they got the top 3 all wrong.

    What was so pedestrian about Chris’s dress? It was the best of the bunch. I mean, I know you enjoy teasing round gay men, but that’s no reason to harsh on the man’s dress. He almost DIED during that mean challenge, for heaven’s sake.

    Yeah, Rami’s shoes were like if Easy Spirit made an ugly tap shoe. And JLo did totally wear that gray, one shouldered number to some function (as was already noted). I can’t find the picture, but it may have been the one that caused all of that nipple controversy (the HORROR!) How could that SOB win when he was so MOB? And can we stop calling those gaudy fabric flowers florschettes, or however you spell it? They are awful and should heretofore be known as GFF or Flowershits.

    I didn’t get Christian’s garment. Hideous fabric, totally unwearable construction. What is the appropriate setting for that thing? Only thing I can think of is some lesbian CEO power breakfast, and I’ll take a pass on that.

    EdHill, my love, I for one AM as excited as you are that this show is back. What could be better.

    PS- Can we talk about how beat Tim Gunn looked in Bryant park? Egads his hair was all stringy and greasy and his complexion was all ruddy. Where the hell had he come from?

  6. Wendy says:

    LQ Thank you, I saw that and felt so badly for him, he was not at his best. But I also noticed he occasionally looked that way on his own show, which I only watched two episodes of so far….I will DVR the rest and try to catch up.

    I really liked Jack’s black, white and turquoise number. It was cute, fun and real people could actually wear it. I liked Chris’ dress because I am a sucker for purple but it did seem a bit slip-ish so only a stick would wear it without unsightly bumps and bubbles. And Kevin’s was fun with the pin strip suiting for the skirt, but his model with the hunched shoulders, yikes! Someone tell this girl it is not auditions for the Hunchback of Notre Dame. Marion’s was hideous as was Carmen’s.

    But I love that PR is back :)

  7. EdHill says:

    Tim is just naturally pale. catch him in direct sunlight like that and it will make one look blotchy. Now let us NEVER talk negatively about him again. EVER.

  8. honeybunny says:

    Leave The Gunn alone!!!!!!!!!!1 Whaaaaaa.


  9. Lizardqueen says:

    I knew I would catch hell for that Tim Gunn remark. Good thing I didn’t mention the part where I wondered if he was the victim of some unsavory park cruiser!

    I really liked Steven’s suit, but not really until the model turned around and had that fun ruffly butt.

  10. minda07 says:

    I thought they were not at Atlas this year, that they were staying in the new Gothem City Apartments? No? Great recap Edhill! I spit out my water when Hiedi said it looked like the model was pooing fabric! I am so glad this show is back.

  11. boolaw says:

    I really liked Jack’s dress too-I could totally see someone wearing it in real life. Rami’s dress was pretty, but the color and style together just screamed Statue of Liberty for me. Also, I hate fabric flowers with a passion.

    I can’t decide if Christian is mildly amusing or incredibly irritating yet.

  12. gir says:

    minda – you’re right, they are at the Gotham City Apts.

    I’m with Wendy on the Chris and Jack love. The purple fabric on Chris’s was so scrumptious, and Jack’s dress is something that I would totally wear on my honeymoon. If I lost 30 lbs and grew about 10 inches. Which could totally happen.

  13. sugarshane says:

    So happy to see PR again!!! Although, I always look forward to the first “crazy” challenge, because it makes for such interesting things. I really like Chris’ dress (he’s the big guy, right?). I thought it has an interesting contrast with the two patterns, and the color was nice.

    Yeah, this show has made fashionistas out of us all.

    I think Christian is gonna cry the first time someone throws some attitude back in his face. I say it’s gonna be Victorya, which I say like someone in Heidi’s home country would (Victor, ya?)

  14. Hiro says:

    I thought Rami’s dress was beautiful, but was not figure-flattering in the least. The model’s boobs looked heavy and weird because of the draping.

    I really enjoy Christian and his complete “I’m kind of a big deal (in my own head)” attitude. I also thought his skirt/jacket were pretty awesome, besides the sort of strange black detailing on the front.

    Also, thank you, Ed, for the “pluperfect “I had pooed””.

  15. EdHill says:

    Hiro, you are my inspiration for all things poo.

  16. may says:

    I,too, am glad this show is back. I think Heidi is gorgeous, and love looking at her.
    I really liked Chris’s dress the best. Rami’s was very nice, but the color turned me off. Jack’s dress was great, but his ab’s were my favorite part!!
    Crazy Elisa is going to give us so much enjoyment in the coming weeks. I hope she stays around awhile, just for that reason.

  17. Clair says:

    Ed, LOVED your Indy/Heidi picture.

  18. sg-dub says:

    Tis true, the models are, shall we say, not pretty. BUT, EdHill, they are all perfect sizes. They are RUNWAY models and the point is that the designers can all use dress forms and their clothes will always fit whomever they get.

    Though some of their walks were “like an ostrich” (says Mrs. dub) and one had boobs that were certainly bigger than expected.

  19. txriotgrrl says:

    my first comment here… great recap!

    i LOOOOVED rami and chris’s creations. i thought rami got the goddess look down pat, and chris’s dress was stunning – very couture IMO.

    elisa is certainly bringing the crazy. and for give me, but sweet p???

  20. Laska says:

    Chris had the best dress.
    Elisa must be crazy, that’s the only reason I can think of her staying.
    Christian’s dress looked straight out of Dynasty. And my 2 year old gave herself a better haircut than he has. And to those people who think that by misspelling their names and getting “blind barber” haircuts it shows me their creative talent- it doesn’t (except Victor, ya? had an awesome dress).

  21. Raul Alegi says:

    I enjoy you because of every one of your work on this blog. Ellie delights in working on investigations and it really is simple to grasp why. A lot of people notice all regarding the compelling tactic you produce insightful information via this blog and foster response from some other people on that idea and our favorite simple princess is in fact studying a whole lot. Take advantage of the remaining portion of the new year. You are conducting a useful job.

  22. Taren Truby says:

    hello how are you today in greek

  23. Elliott Holmes says:

    Souls in theGreat Morning, I just stopped in to go to your website and assumed I would say I enjoyed myself. Waves

  24. Candi Mowdy says:

    The thinking behind stunning tiffany jewelry offers is almost while beautiful as the exact tiffany jewellery sections ourselves. tiffany co jewellery should bring rear experiences of an essential association or perhaps produce a splendid,discount tiffany and co jewelry, in addition to significant affair additional remarkable. Learning about lots of tiffany co bead bracelet can aid an individual with safe guarding that more.

  25. you can check here says:

    Basically, can i look for web sites that fit what I wish to find about? Does people learn how to Read through web sites by theme or anything that on blogger? .

  26. Makeda Galacio says:

    The clarity in your post is simply nice and i could assume you are an expert on this subject.

  27. Micah Spafford says:

    The fantastic media is that often a lot of amazing online stores for example happen to be giving clients by using an great alternative option to the typical, traditional sellers. Opt for ,,customer as well as look and / or keep operator looking to get remarkably great deals in the recent manner brandnames including Juicy Couture tracksuit wholesale programs, how’s that for a person on the internet electric outlet it is best to take into account.

  28. my review here says:

    I’m seeking some great endeavor web logs to increase my google and bing readers that will be worthy subsequent to with an regular basis. How can you make and suggestions? I have got Seth Godin’s by now. Thank you! . . Whenever you advised me why you wanted these web sites., it may well even be important.

  29. Our site says:

    Do you know the absolute best web logs and sites specifically for perusing and literature?

  30. see it here says:

    What sites for political commentary will you advise me to check out?

  31. try here says:

    I might really like to generate a web-site but.. I’m unclear which web logs maximum benefit traffic? What sort of personal blogs does one surfing? I largely surf pictures blog posts and clothing web logs. Just buying a survey in this case kudos! .

  32. check over here says:

    What is the website making it easy to follow podcasts and blogging sites? I don’t have an iPod, does that factor? .

  33. read more says:

    precisely, what are some sought after and really good websites for websites? ?? .

  34. here says:

    Tips on how to discover various web sites on Blogger with search term or investigation?

  35. download Transformers says:

    My family always say that I am killing my time here at web, except I
    know I am getting familiarity everyday by reading thes good articles
    or reviews.

  36. download 8 ball pool hack tool android says:

    Undeniably consider that that you said. Your favorite justification seemed to be
    on the internet the simplest thing to be aware of.
    I say to you, I certainly get irked at the same time as other folks consider worries that they plainly don’t recognize about.
    You controlled to hit the nail upon the highest as smartly as
    outlined out the entire thing with no need side effect , people can take a signal.
    Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

  37. Manual Helstad says:

    property for sale and to rent London Battersea and sw8

  38. kitchen remodel new nursing shea homes bay area california says:

    Hі jujst ѡanted to ցive you a brief heads up and let you knoա a feew of thе images aren’t loading properly.
    I’m not sure why Ƅut I think its a linking іssue.

    I’νe trieԁ it in two different browsers and both
    show the same outcome.

    my homepage: kitchen remodel new nursing shea homes bay area california

  39. Claudia says:

    My spouse and I stumbled over Һerе different web page and thought I should check things out.
    I like ѡhat I see so now i am following you. Look forward to going over your web page yet again.

    My blog borax clorox and mold removal (Claudia)

  40. Natisha Garvin says:

    Hello, your posts made me a bug of your blog. Very informative! Thanks

  41. Freddie says:

    Heya! I just wawnted to ask if you ever have any trouble
    with hackers? My last blog (wordpress) wwas hacked and
    I ended up losing a few months of hard work due tto no bback
    up. Do you have any methods to prevent hackers?

    Look at my homepage :: 1 800 water katrina damage photos (Freddie)

  42. Palo alto says:

    hey there and thank you for ykur info – I have certainly picked up anything new from right here.
    I did however expertise a few technical issues using this site,
    since I experiencd to reload the web site man times previous to I could get it to load properly.I had been wondering iif your hosting is
    OK? Not thzt I aam complaining, but slow loading instances times will very frequently
    affect your placement in google and can damage your quality score if advertising and marketing
    with Adwords. Well I am adding this RSS to my e-mail and could look out for a lot more of your
    respective exciting content. Ensure that you update this again very soon.

    Stop by my blog post … Palo alto

  43. says:

    Pretty! This has been an incredibly wonderful article.

    Thanks for providing this information.

  44. vitamin c serum says:

    I have seen that these days, more and more people are increasingly being attracted to cams and the industry of pictures. However, being a photographer, you should first shell out so much time deciding the model of video camera to buy and also moving out of store to store just so you can buy the lowest priced camera of the trademark you have decided to settle on. But it won’t end now there. You also have to contemplate whether you can purchase a digital digital camera extended warranty. Thanks alot : ) for the good tips I acquired from your weblog.

  45. For Sale By Owner Saskatoon Saskatchewan says:

    I like this site its a master peace ! Glad I identified this on google .

  46. mattress reviews says:

    This paragraph gives clear idea designed for the new people of blogging, that actually how to do blogging and site-building.

  47. veni vidi vici says:

    I saw two other comparable posts although yours was the most beneficial so a whole lot

  48. Ayur Skin Renewal Free Trial says:

    Within the other hand, it doesn’t matter how high quality you might be along with solving the latest platform, in due course it is possible to utilize a situation within the spot you need to want to do a couple support approaching; moreover influenced by your actual age moreover gym, plus the dietary of any caravan it is actually a notably difficult physical fitness. caravan touch up paint

  49. en iyi Cift tarafli 3M Bant says:

    Fascinating column , I am going to spend far more time reading about this topic

  50. cheap fifa 15 coins says:

    I found your blog web site on google and verify just a few of your early posts. Continue to keep up the very good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Looking for forward to reading more from you afterward!

  51. traducere romana daneza says:

    Many people may well assume this may have an effect on my social expertise, but when something it gave me far more abilities and previously as I used to be normally travelling and had to turn out to be incredibly independent.

  52. pyrex says:

    Oh Kip, you’re a genius! I never buy cherries for this really reasonn. Can�t wait to go discover one.

  53. goodreau says:

    I went to a lunch now at Bistro 31 of the global Culinary School that featured Molecular Gastronomy meals. One of the things they served was a yogurt �egg�. I was provide this internet site as a place to receive dishes. I looked at the recipe collection however, didn’t fian an actual recipe for these fantastic �eggs�. I am completely hot for this type of cooking and want specific directions. Help Please.

Leave a Comment